Ice cubes melting in salt water and freshwater (post 1/4)
Experiment to visualize the effects of density differences on ocean circulation.
This is the first post in a series on one of my favorite in-class experiments; I have so much to say about it that we’ll have to break it up into several posts.
Post 1 (this post) will present one setup of the experiment, but no explanations yet.
Post 2 will present how I use this experiment in GEOF130, including explanations.
Post 3 will discuss how this experiment can be used in many different setups and
Post 4 will discuss different purposes this experiment can be used in (seriously – you can use it for anything! almost…).
So, let’s get to the experiment. First, ice cubes are inserted into two cups, one filled with fresh water at room temperature, the other one filled with salt water at room temperature. In this case, the ice cubes are dyed with food coloring and you will quickly see why:
Ice cubes are added to cups filled with water at room temperature: fresh water on the left, salt water on the right.
As the ice cubes start to melt, we can see the dyed melt water behaving very differently in fresh water and salt water. In fresh water, it quickly sinks to the bottom of the cup, whereas in salt water it forms a layer at the surface.
Melt water from the ice cube is sinking towards the bottom in the cup containing fresh water (on the left), but it is staying near the surface in the cup containing salt water (on the right).
After approximately 10 minutes, the ice cube in freshwater has melted completely, whereas in salt water there are still remains of the ice cube.
After 10 minutes, the ice cube in the fresh water cup has melted completely (left), whereas the one in the salt water cup is not gone completely yet (right).
Why should one of the ice cubes melt so much faster than the other one, even though both cups contained water at the same (room) temperature? Many of you will know the answer to this, and others will be able to deduce it from the different colors of the water in the cups, but the rest of you will have to wait for an explanation until the next post on this topic – we will be doing this experiment in class on Tuesday and I can’t spoil the fun for the students by posting the answer today already! But if you want to watch a movie of the whole experiment: Here it is!
(Yes, this really is how I spend my rainy Sunday mornings, and I love it!)
– I first saw this experiment at the 2012 Ocean Sciences meeting when Bob Chen of COSEE introduced it in a workshop “understanding how people learn”. COSEE has several instructions for this experiment online, for example here and here. My take on it in the “on the Cutting Edge – Professional Development for Geoscience Faculty” collection here.
Ice cubes melting in fresh water and salt water (post 2/4) | Adventures in Oceanography and Teaching says:
[…] might remember the “ice cubes melting in fresh water and salt water experiment” from a couple of days ago. Today we are going to talk about it again, but with a little twist on it. See, when I showed you […]
Melting ice cubes reloaded | says:
[…] Ice cubes melting in salt water and freshwater (post 1/4) […]
Melting ice cubes, again | says:
[…] Ice cubes melting in salt water and freshwater (post 1/4) […]
Dangers of blogging, or ice cubes melting in fresh water and salt water | says:
[…] to share their images and details from our course. So when I was recently trying to do my usual melting of ice cubes in fresh water and salt water experiment (that I dedicated a whole series on, details below this post), the unavoidable happened. I asked […]
Melting ice cubes – one experiment, many ways (post 3/4) | says:
[…] part 1 and 2 of this series, I showed two different ways of using the “ice cubes melting in fresh […]
On how ice freezes from salt water | says:
[…] But I accidentally stumbled upon a great visualization when preparing dyed ice cubes for the melting ice cube experiment (see this post) when all my ice cubes came out like […]
Melting ice cubes – what contexts to use this experiment in (post 4/4) – Mirjam S. Glessmer says:
[…] you might have noticed, I really like the “ice cubes melting in fresh water and in salt water” experiment. Initially, I had only three posts planned on the topic (post 1 and 2 showing different variation […]
Why folic acid might be good for people, but not so good for tank experiments – Mirjam S. Glessmer says:
[…] Ice cubes melting in salt water and freshwater (post 1/4) […]
Ice cubes melting at the bottom of the beakers – Mirjam S. Glessmer says:
[…] Ice cubes melting in salt water and freshwater (post 1/4) […]
Passion for Ocean 2019 – Elin Darelius & team's scientific adventures says:
[…] a glass of sea water – which one will melt first? Do you know? You can try at home – or visit Mirjam’s blog to find […]